Bill McKibben on tax bill/Keystone XL: WTF?

  • Published on December 20th, 2011

By Bill McKibben
350.org

Dear Friends,

About 48 hours ago, I told you we’d have a clearer picture of what was going on with the pipeline fight in 48 hours.

I was wrong, mistaken, and also incorrect. As it stands now, things in Washington couldn’t be muddier. The Senate, with the White House’s consent, passed a payroll tax cut plan with a rider attached that would have forced a speedy review of Keystone. That sounds bad — except that spokespeople from the Obama administration said quite bluntly that if they were forced to do a quick review they’d deny the permit.

That sounds good — except that now the Tea Party caucus in the House has decided they don’t want the payroll tax cut, and they do want the Senate to come back to DC for more talks, and…you get the drift. At least for the moment, Keystone is flotsam on the unchartable tides of DC politics.

We’re monitoring it as closely as we can, and if anything definitive emerges from the money-filled rooms, or if there’s any obvious action that you can take beyond all the emailing and phone-calling to date, we’ll tell you immediately. Keep an eye on your email inbox, please — and in the meantime we’ll be posting play-by-play updates to our Twitter feed and our Facebook page. You can also join our rapid-response mobile network by using your cell phone to text the word “PLUGIN” to the number 50555.*

Here’s one thing that’s emerged more plainly with each passing day. Right now in Washington, money rules. Sooner or later Big Oil will ram Keystone, and fracking, and a thousand other bad ideas down our throats unless we manage to change the system. That’s what we’re going to have to work on next year if we have any hope of ever bringing climate change under control. I think part of the problem is: we’ve come to feel that money’s hammerlock on policy is sad but completely inevitable. We’ve let ourselves be cynical, which is understandable (the Capitol should have an Exxon sign out front, and a couple of pumps, and a grubby bathroom) but also a bit weak.

Instead, I think we need to stand up for a certain kind of naïveté. We need to say it’s not right that the 234 House members who voted for Keystone last week had taken $42 million in dirty energy money. It’s no different than if before next weekend’s Patriots-Miami game, the owner of the Dolphins trotted out to midfield and handed each referee ten grand. It stinks.

Next year, we’ll be delivering this message to Representatives and Senators everywhere: if the energy industry is giving you presents, you shouldn’t be giving them presents back. Not with our money, not with our landscape, and not with our planet. You’ve given us a lot of suggestions in the last couple of weeks about how to take on the money pollution that corrupts our political system — but if you have more send them in to “ideas@350.org.” And rest up over the holidays because we’re going to need you in fighting trim come 2012.

Apologies again for misleading you about how quickly we’d know the score in DC. I underestimated, not for the first and not for the last time, how screwed up the place really is. But we can do something about that. And we will.

Onwards,

Bill McKibben for the whole team at 350.org

About the Author

4 comments

  • thank you for delivering truth, im from alberta and people here dont understand or care about big oil, beecause it drives our economy and our provincial government, whose been in power for 40 years, are owned and financed by big oil and dont forget our corperate shill prime minister,canadians will regret not keeping a leash on harper and the oil copanies……

  • Thank you Bill McLibben and workers at 350.org for being there and leading the path for a sane and healthy planet. Without you and others like you I would be cynical! Everyone reading this comment, please be heard and seen by your elected officials and stand up to the dirty oil/coil/tar sands folks that only want a quick buck and leave an Earth with a climate that your children will curse us for.

Comments are closed.